“There is no longer any doubt that the current administration committed war crimes.”

So says retired Antonio Taguba, who oversaw the review of the Abu Ghraib scandal, and was then forced out when the report told the truth, in the introduction to the report from Physicians for Human Rights on torture under US detention, which uses, among other things, the roadmap of scars on its victims:

Neither the Bush administration nor the Pentagon commented on the unpublished report yesterday. President Bush has repeatedly said he does not condone torture and allows interrogation techniques that are aggressive but legal.

The report challenges that contention with a detailed physical and psychological profile of each of the former detainees. In two of the cases, the medical investigators had access to the subjects’ recent medical records. All 11 men were given pseudonyms for their protection, according to the report.

The doctors found that “Kamal,” an Iraqi in his late 40s held from September 2003 until June 2004 at Abu Ghraib, has a lesion near his right ear that is “consistent with a healed cut from a sharp-edged instrument,” according to the report. He also had another wound by his left ear, described as “a healed puncture injury” that matches “Kamal’s description of being stabbed with a screwdriver in his cheek by a soldier,” the report states.

Psychologically, “Kamal’s clinical presentation, reported history of abuse, and the result of psychological testing support the presence of several psychiatric diagnoses,” including depression, a panic disorder, and post-traumatic stress disorder, according to the report.

A subject named “Amir,” an Iraqi in his late 20s held in Abu Ghraib prison from August 2003 to January 2005, “showed signs of rectal tearing that are highly consistent with his report of having been sodomized with a broomstick,” the report found.

“Yasser,” another Abu Ghraib detainee in his mid-40s, had scars on his thumbs and irregularities in the contours of his tongue, according to the report. The medical team concluded that the damage supports his contention that his American captors subjected him to electric shocks.

The problem here torture always follows the soldiers home. The people who were ordered to to this will come home, and many of them will end up in law enforcement, where they will do the same to someone who they think is not sufficiently respectful at a traffic stop.

The only answer is accountability at the very highest levels. By this, I do not mean that it stops at Rumsfeld. Bush and Cheney need to spend most of the rest of their lives in jail.

Leave a Reply